Oracles and Artificial Intelligence
Raw link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hb3fxgLMlos
In this ~35 minute walk I talk about philosophical themes related to artificial intelligence and our attitudes towards it. In outline:
- There are similarities between modern attitudes towards AI and how ancient folks would treat oracles as authoritative and infallible.
- Story about the Oracle of Apollon in Delphi and how it would provide non-answers to questions that could not be reduced to a “yes or no”.
- Explanation of how we must think about complexity and what our attitude should be towards presumed oracular wisdom.
- Oracles or AI are neither good nor bad. It depends on how we deal with them. Discussion about being gullible or not.
- Story about Prometheus, the know-how of fire, and whether tools are good/bad for us.
- Avoiding extremes by trying to be less presumptuous about our capacity for good/evil.
- Switching gears to individuals affairs. Talk about feelings of expertise; of setting goals and accomplishing them.
- There is value to be had in mastery, in not copy-pasting answers, but in actually understanding things in-depth.
- Talk about how prior notes/work frames and limits our creativity. AI can do the same if we get in the bad habit of not putting in the hard work.
- Connection between these insights and what I covered at length in my presentation about “productivity, honesty, and accountability structures”: https://protesilaos.com/books/2023-02-21-productivity-honesty-accountability-structures/.
- Do not underestimate your potential and how you can feel inexorable when you put in the effort.